Authoritative Sources for Derivative Classification

Derivative classification is a critical aspect of information security in the realm of national defense and intelligence. It involves the process of using existing classified information to create new documents or materials that are also classified. Understanding which sources are authoritative for derivative classification is vital for ensuring that sensitive information remains protected and that new materials are properly marked and handled.

Understanding Derivative Classification

Derivative classification refers to the process of incorporating, paraphrasing, restating, or generating new forms of information that are based on or derived from already classified sources. The primary goal of derivative classification is to ensure that new documents retain the appropriate classification markings and are protected against unauthorized disclosure.

Key Terms and Concepts

• Classified Information: Information that has been determined to require protection against unauthorized disclosure for reasons of national security.
• Original Classification: The initial determination that information requires protection against unauthorized disclosure.
• Derivative Classification: The process of classifying new material derived from or based on information that is already classified.
• Authoritative Source: A source that is recognized and trusted to provide accurate and reliable information for the purpose of classification.

The Importance of Authoritative Sources

In the context of derivative classification, an authoritative source is crucial because it ensures that the new material created from classified information maintains the correct classification level. Using non-authoritative sources can lead to misclassification, which may result in either over-classification or under-classification, both of which have significant security implications.

Examples of Authoritative Sources

Authoritative sources for derivative classification typically include:

1. Security Classification Guides (SCGs): These guides provide detailed instructions on how specific information should be classified. They are developed by Original Classification Authorities (OCAs) and are a primary resource for derivative classifiers.
2. Previously Classified Documents: Documents that have already been classified by an OCA serve as authoritative sources. When using information from these documents, the new material must be classified consistently with the original classification.
3. Classified Databases: Databases containing classified information are also considered authoritative sources. Derivative classifiers must ensure that any new material derived from these databases is marked accordingly.
4. Directives and Regulations: Government directives and regulations related to classification, such as Executive Orders and Department of Defense instructions, provide authoritative guidance on how information should be classified and handled.

Security Classification Guides (SCGs)

SCGs are one of the most important authoritative sources for derivative classification. They provide comprehensive guidelines on how to classify information related to specific programs, projects, or activities. SCGs are developed by OCAs who have the authority to make original classification decisions. These guides typically include:

• Classification Levels: SCGs specify the classification levels (e.g., Confidential, Secret, Top Secret) for different types of information.
• Marking Instructions: They provide detailed instructions on how to mark documents and materials derived from classified information.
• Declassification Instructions: SCGs include guidelines on when and how classified information can be declassified or downgraded.

Previously Classified Documents

Using previously classified documents as authoritative sources for derivative classification ensures consistency and accuracy in the classification process. When creating new materials based on existing classified documents, it is essential to:

• Match Classification Levels: The new material must be classified at the same level as the source document.
• Apply Proper Markings: All classification markings from the source document must be accurately reflected in the new material.
• Follow Dissemination Controls: Any dissemination controls (e.g., NOFORN, REL TO) must be maintained in the new material.

Classified Databases

Classified databases are repositories of information that have been deemed classified. Derivative classifiers using these databases must:

• Verify Classification Levels: Ensure that the classification level of the derived information matches that of the source data.
• Apply Consistent Markings: Accurately apply classification markings to any new material generated from the database.
• Maintain Data Integrity: Ensure that the integrity of the classified information is preserved in the new material.

Directives and Regulations

Government directives and regulations provide the overarching framework for classification and are considered authoritative sources. Key directives include:

• Executive Orders: Such as Executive Order 13526, which outlines the classification system for national security information.
• Department of Defense Instructions: Such as DoD Instruction 5200.01, which provides detailed guidelines on information security and classification.

The Role of Original Classification Authorities (OCAs)

OCAs play a pivotal role in the classification process. They are responsible for making original classification decisions and for developing SCGs. OCAs ensure that derivative classifiers have the necessary guidance to accurately classify new materials. Key responsibilities of OCAs include:

• Creating and Updating SCGs: Developing and maintaining SCGs to provide clear classification guidelines.
• Providing Training and Support: Offering training and support to derivative classifiers to ensure they understand and correctly apply classification markings.
• Conducting Reviews and Audits: Regularly reviewing and auditing classified materials to ensure compliance with classification guidelines.

Best Practices for Derivative Classification

To ensure the accuracy and integrity of derivative classification, it is important to follow best practices, including:

• Thorough Training: Derivative classifiers should receive comprehensive training on classification policies, SCGs, and marking requirements.
• Accurate Marking: Always apply the correct classification markings, dissemination controls, and declassification instructions.
• Regular Reviews: Conduct regular reviews and audits of classified materials to ensure compliance with guidelines.
• Consulting OCAs: When in doubt, consult OCAs or security classification guides for clarification on classification issues.

Challenges in Derivative Classification

Despite the availability of authoritative sources, derivative classification can present several challenges:

• Complexity of Information: The complexity of some classified information can make it difficult to determine the appropriate classification level.
• Consistency in Marking: Ensuring consistency in marking across different documents and materials can be challenging.
• Keeping Up with Changes: Staying updated with changes in classification guides, directives, and regulations requires continuous effort.

Conclusion

Derivative classification is a critical function in the protection of national security information. Identifying and using authoritative sources is essential for ensuring that new materials derived from classified information are accurately marked and protected. By adhering to security classification guides, relying on previously classified documents, utilizing classified databases, and following directives and regulations, derivative classifiers can maintain the integrity and confidentiality of sensitive information. Continuous training, regular reviews, and consultation with OCAs are vital components of a robust derivative classification program. Through these efforts, organizations can effectively manage the classification process and safeguard national security.